“Boswellia Solution” vs “Boswellia”: China Cosmetic Brand Fined for Misleading Ingredient Claims

Regulatory Crackdown on Cosmetic “Wordplay”
A recent enforcement action by Guangzhou Baiyun District Market Supervision Administration highlights growing scrutiny over cosmetic ingredient claims. The case revolves around ​DoraDuoShang, a popular Kuaishou beauty brand, which was fined 280,000 RMB for misleading consumers about Boswellia (Pro-Xylane) concentrations in its anti-aging serums

1.

---

​Case Overview: The 280,000 RMB Penalty

The investigation revealed critical discrepancies:

• ​Product Claims: Exterior packaging and labels prominently displayed “10% Boswellia”
• ​Actual Content: Independent testing confirmed only 2.5% pure hydroxypropyl tetrahydropyrantriol (Boswellia active ingredient)
• ​Ingredient Deception: The product used “Boswellia solution” containing 20-30% active ingredient diluted with water and glycols

This violates China’s ​Cosmetic Labeling Management Measures, mandating accurate disclosure of effective component concentrations

2.

---

​Technical Clarification: Boswellia ≠ Boswellia Solution

Term	Definition	Regulatory Requirement
​Boswellia	Pure hydroxypropyl tetrahydropyrantriol (active anti-aging agent)	Must meet minimum 0.5% efficacy
​Boswellia Solution	Proprietary raw material containing 20-30% Boswellia + solvents	Requires clear concentration labeling

Industry experts confirm:

“Some brands exploit terminology loopholes by labeling solvent-based ingredients as ‘pure Boswellia’. This creates false efficacy perceptions.” – Cosmetic R&D Engineer Zhang Taijun

3

---

​Industry Impact: Regulatory Trends & Market Shifts

1. ​Enhanced Compliance Checks
   • 2023 saw 23+ similar cases with penalties up to 1 million RMB
   • New draft regulations mandate ​dual-column labeling (active ingredient vs. total solution)
2. ​Consumer Awareness Surge
   • 68% of Chinese consumers now verify ingredient concentrations via apps
   • Social media campaigns (#BoswelliaScam) have 120 million+ views
3. ​Supply Chain Adjustments
   • Genuine 98% pure Boswellia now trades at 20,000 RMB/kg (+300% YoY)
   • 56% of OEM factories implement ​third-party purity audits

---

​Expert Recommendations for Consumers

1. ​Three-Step Verification
   • Cross-check ​National Medical Products Administration (NMPA) ingredient databases
   • Calculate effective concentration:
     Solution Concentration × Active Ingredient Percentage
   • Demand ​third-party test reports from retailers
2. ​Brand Accountability
   • Leading domestic brands now adopt ​**”Active Ingredient First”** labeling standards
   • Platforms like Tmall and Pinduoduo have removed 1,200+ non-compliant product listings

---

Conclusion:
This enforcement action signals a new era of transparency in China’s 500-billion-yuan cosmetics market. As regulations tighten, brands face pressure to abandon “marketing math” and prioritize genuine innovation. Consumers, armed with better information, are driving demand for authenticity – a trend likely to reshape global beauty standards.